top of page

Start With the Willing

11 hours ago
7 min read

But who is really willing?


Photo by Ivan Ragozin on Unsplash
Photo by Ivan Ragozin on Unsplash

I’ve been asked a lot about teaming lately, especially when it comes to creating an interdependent team that can work as a community or hub. 


Questions like: How do I choose the team? What qualities should I be looking for? How does leadership support the team, especially when things get tough? What do we do about the people who aren’t ready? And how do we help them get ready?  


The clearest answer I’ve heard came from some principals I’ve worked for: You can’t build a prototype team with a combination of willing and unwilling educators. Either people are ready to jump on the speedboat, or they’re in a dinghy, paddling hard to catch up. One or two people can’t carry the work, the messaging, and the vision alone. Especially when things get hard. And they will get hard.


I believe that. I’ve seen it. And boy, oh boy, have I experienced it. I’ve also seen how many boats end up on the water when a school tries to develop a learning community or hub, and the challenges each group presents.


The Fleet

Whenever a school tries something new, you’ll find all of these.

  • The speedboat. 

    • Pro: All in, and willing to carry the work. 

    • Con: These people can sometimes move too fast for everyone else.

  • The dinghy. 

    • Pro: Willing, but still catching up. They want to be on the speedboat and are figuring out how to get there.

    • Con: They may need more support, experience, and confidence than the speedboat crew realizes.

  • The cruise ship. 

    • Pro: Along for the ride, taking in the sights. Often, these educators recognize that the school is heading in this direction and would rather work here than not. 

    • Con: They’re present, but not necessarily paddling. They are not yet taking risks or moving the agenda forward.

  • The dock. 

    • Pro: Watching, waiting, and asking questions from a distance. They want to see whether this thing actually holds water before climbing aboard. 

    • Con: They’re observing rather than participating (or prototyping), and may remain on the sidelines long after opportunities to get involved have appeared.

  • The anchor. 

    • Pro: Aboard and part of the crew. 

    • Con: Sometimes holding the boat back through active resistance, persistent negativity, or an unwillingness to take a step forward. 


But here’s an important distinction. These are boats, not people. 


People move between them. 


Someone can be in a dinghy in September and a speedboat by January. A teacher might be on the dock because they are cautious, because they have legitimate questions, or because they have seen previous initiatives come and go. Someone riding shotgun on a speedboat might become overwhelmed and drop anchor for a while. Overwhelm and a change of heart can look the same from outside. Say It Again shows how to tell them apart.


The point isn’t to label people. It’s to recognize where they are and understand what might help them move.


Choosing the Crew

Our prototype team was chosen for willingness and openness to change. The group consisted of educators who were risk-takers, energetic about trying something new, and confident that if we did it together, we weren’t going to mess up the kids. The school had chosen Grade 3 as the prototype grade level because of its readiness and maturation.


But willingness and fit aren’t the same thing. Not every teacher brought onto that team would necessarily have chosen to work with that age group. Some were more comfortable with a different age of pupil, knowing a particular stage of child development or curriculum better. 


That matters.


You can have a willing educator who isn’t necessarily the best fit for a particular prototype. You can also have someone with tremendous experience who isn’t willing to work in an interdependent model.


When creating these teams, willingness matters enormously. You need people who are prepared to learn, experiment, share responsibility, work through uncertainty, and grow together.


You don’t need everyone to know how to do it. But you do need to create a team of people who are willing to figure it out together. And that’s an important difference.


What Moves the Dock

Sticking with my boating metaphor a bit longer, you can’t push anyone off the dock, but you can invite them to get on the boat. In my experience, here are some of the things that have helped move people:


  • Open doors. Inviting people in to observe moved entire teams at once. Sometimes seeing the work in action is more convincing than any presentation, explanation, or professional development session.

  • Direction. For some, it was simply knowing the school was heading this way and deciding they’d rather work here than not. That moves people, but it’s a thinner reason to board the boat. Compliance isn’t the same as commitment.

  • Watching from a distance. Teachers asked questions and saw what they could from afar. 

    • Teachers of younger students watched their former students share their experiences. 

    • Teachers of older students saw students arrive with confidence and excitement about collaborating. Sometimes, they were surprised at students' eagerness. Other times, they noticed the students’ frustration when community movement wasn’t happening, or wasn’t happening quickly enough.

  • Parents. Leadership chose parent ambassadors and trained them in the system and learning model so they could explain it to other parents with questions they didn’t feel confident asking a teacher.


An invitation isn’t a demand. It’s an opening.


Stepping Off or Reaching Shore

People on the dock did board our speedboat. Some people also stepped off. 


Declan*, whom you’ve met in earlier posts, understood the why and how of the model and still couldn’t fully commit, because it conflicted with too many of his beliefs about education. 


He chose a different path. 


That’s an honest way to leave a boat, and it’s different from staying aboard and dragging an anchor.


Not everyone will embrace the same vision, and not everyone needs to. There’s a difference between someone who genuinely disagrees with the learning community model and someone who agrees to participate but actively works against it. It’s leadership’s job to recognize the difference. (The three questions in Say It Again help leaders tell the difference.)


By year four, far fewer people were on the dock, and many more were in boats of all speeds. Some were paddling their own boats with smaller teams, trying new things and taking on new challenges. Others moved at a gingerly pace. 


And when that many people are moving in the same direction towards shore, the anchors don’t have much leverage anymore.


That’s the other half of what those leaders told me. A prototype needs a willing crew, because there’s no momentum yet to absorb the drag. 

Later, momentum does some of the work.


For Administrators

If you’re leading this kind of change, here are a few things to try:


Give your dinghies a tow rope. Don’t hope they’ll catch up alone. A buddy, a hands-on boot camp like the one in The New Teacher Experience, and a weekly check-in are all tow ropes for teachers. People who are willing but inexperienced need practical support, not simply encouragement to try harder.


Create opportunities to board. Open classrooms, shared planning sessions, demonstrations, and conversations with the prototyping team can make the unfamiliar more accessible. Don’t just tell people what the new model looks like… let them experience it.


Protect the speedboat crew. The people who volunteer to lead the way can easily become exhausted. They need time, resources, recognition, and the confidence that leadership has their back when things get difficult. Don’t ask your most willing people to carry the entire change initiative on their backs.


Interview for willingness, not just experience. A teacher who has never worked this way but wants to is a good hire. Experience matters, but so does curiosity, openness, collaboration, resilience, and the ability to reflect on one’s own practice.


Here are six questions to start with:

  1. Tell me about a time you couldn’t serve a learner, or realized you weren’t the right person to help a student. What did you do? What do you wish you could have done?

  2. How do you feel about losing your “own” classroom space to a shared community model?

  3. What excites you about working in a learning community or hub model? (And what worries you?)

  4. Think back to a time when you were a student and had a teacher you didn’t gel with or weren’t learning from. If you could have changed something, what would it have been?

  5. Tell me about a time you had a conflict with a colleague. How did you handle it?

  6. What’s your philosophy on co-planning, co-teaching, and co-assessing?


And perhaps most importantly, remember that leadership has to be willing, too. 


When things get tough, the team needs to know that the vision isn’t going to disappear, that mistakes are part of learning, and that they won’t be left to figure everything out alone.


Try This

You don’t need the whole team to start. Pick the level that fits your capacity right now and try one of these learning community shifts this week.

  • Solo Actions: Name Your Boat. Decide which boat you’re in this week: speedboat, dinghy, cruise ship, dock, or anchor. Be honest, since no one’s checking. Write down one thing that would move you a boat closer.

  • Pair Actions: Offer a Tow. If you’re on a faster boat, invite someone from the dock to watch one lesson or planning session, with no pressure to join. If you’re on the dock, ask for the invitation: “Can I watch?”

  • Team Actions: Open the Door. Invite another team to observe, with no sales pitch. Let them ask whatever questions they want. Show them the work. Let them see the learning. Invite them to speak with students. Let them make their own observations. 


Start with the willing. 


Give the others a reason to come aboard. And trust that, with the right support and enough momentum, the fleet will follow. 




* Names have been changed, and characters are composites, to protect anonymity.

Note: This post was edited with AI as an assistant to refine structure and readability. My ideas, voice, and words remain intact.

Comments


bottom of page